In short
Someone is bogus self-employed (scheinselbstständig) if they present themselves as self-employed but actually work like an employee: following instructions and integrated into the client's organisation (Sec. 7 (1) SGB IV). In that case, there is employment for social security purposes, and the client must pay social security contributions retrospectively, usually for up to four years, and for up to thirty years in the case of intent. What the contract says matters less than how the work is actually done. A status determination procedure with the German Pension Insurance gives certainty.
Key points
- What counts is being bound by instructions and integration, not the label in the contract.
- The German Pension Insurance decides based on an overall assessment of all circumstances (Sec. 7a (2) SGB IV).
- The "5/6 rule" concerns self-employed persons similar to employees: they remain self-employed but are subject to compulsory pension insurance.
- Contributions become time-barred after four years, and after thirty years if deliberately withheld (Sec. 25 SGB IV).
- The client bears the back payment largely alone and risks criminal liability (Sec. 266a StGB).
- A well-drafted contract helps but does not protect you if practice looks different.
Contents
What is bogus self-employment?
A person is formally self-employed, issues invoices and often has a freelance or service contract. In reality, however, they work like an employee. Under Sec. 7 (1) SGB IV, indications of employment are working according to instructions and integration into the work organisation of the person giving the instructions.
The problem: contributions to pension, health, long-term care and unemployment insurance must be paid for employees. In the case of bogus self-employment, this has not happened. If the pension insurance establishes this, for example during an audit, it demands back payments.
Self-check: ten criteria
| Criterion | Indicates employment | Indicates self-employment |
|---|---|---|
| Instructions | client determines time, place and manner of work | you decide yourself how and when you work |
| Integration | own workplace, company email, part of the duty roster | you work from your own premises with your own resources |
| Clients | essentially only one, permanently | several clients |
| Entrepreneurial risk | fixed pay per hour or month, no risk of loss | fixed prices, own capital, risk of loss |
| Own staff | none | own employees |
| Advertising and market presence | no own website, no acquisition | own market presence, acquisition |
| Work equipment | provided by the client | own work equipment |
| Substitution | you must work personally | you may be represented or use subcontractors |
| Activity | same work as the client's employees | a defined project or piece of work |
| History | previously employed by the same client | none |
No single criterion is decisive. The more points in the left column apply, the greater the risk. The pension insurance offers its own questionnaires.
The 5/6 rule and self-employed persons similar to employees
The "5/6 rule" is often confused with bogus self-employment. It concerns genuinely self-employed people who:
- do not regularly employ an employee subject to compulsory insurance and
- work permanently and essentially for only one client (Sec. 2 sentence 1 no. 9 SGB VI).
The pension insurance assumes "essentially" if at least five sixths of turnover comes from one client. The previous year's income and expected future income count. The same applies to a contractual exclusivity. It is not enough for the contract to allow other clients; they must actually be proven. Consequence: you remain self-employed but must pay pension insurance contributions yourself. Business founders can be exempted for an initial period.
Status determination procedure: how it works
Client and contractor can apply to the German Pension Insurance (Deutsche Rentenversicherung Bund) for a binding determination of whether there is employment or self-employment (Sec. 7a SGB IV).
- Application: in writing or electronically, jointly or separately.
- Questionnaires: Both sides describe the collaboration, and contracts are attached.
- Hearing: Before an unfavourable decision, those involved are heard.
- Notice: The DRV decides on the basis of an overall assessment. An objection to the notice is possible.
- Forecast and group determination: Since 2022, status can be determined before the work begins. Clients with many similar assignments can apply for a group determination, and three-party arrangements with an agency can be clarified in one procedure.
If the application is made within one month of the start of the work, a determined obligation to pay insurance may, under certain conditions, only begin with the notice.
Consequences for clients
- Back payment: Employer and employee shares for all branches of insurance. The client can only recover the employee share from the contractor to a very limited extent.
- Late payment surcharges: 1 percent of the outstanding contributions for each month or part of a month (Sec. 24 SGB IV), unless the client was unaware through no fault of their own.
- Limitation: four years after the end of the calendar year in which the contributions became due, thirty years in the case of intent (Sec. 25 SGB IV).
- Criminal liability: An employer who withholds contributions commits an offence under Sec. 266a StGB, punishable by up to five years' imprisonment or a fine.
- Employment law and tax: The contractor can assert employee rights such as holiday. The tax office is not bound by the pension insurance's determination but may also assume an employment relationship and claim wage tax.
Example
A company engages an IT freelancer for four years at 5,000 euros a month. The DRV determines that there is employment. The total social security contributions must be paid retrospectively, roughly around 40 percent of pay up to the contribution assessment ceilings. With 48 months × 5,000 euros = 240,000 euros, that is roughly 90,000 to 100,000 euros, plus late payment surcharges.
Consequences for contractors
- Retrospectively covered by social insurance, usually without having to pay the employee shares yourself.
- Protection under employment law, for example protection against dismissal and holiday entitlement, may apply.
- If the tax office also considers you an employee, you have wrongly charged VAT. This must be reversed.
- For self-employed persons similar to employees: own compulsory pension insurance.
Drafting contracts correctly
A contract cannot prevent bogus self-employment if practice is different. However, it should match the actual collaboration and make the self-employment comprehensible.
Checklist: freelance contract
- A specific project or defined service instead of general collaboration
- No fixed working hours or attendance obligations
- Free choice of place and work equipment
- Right to use third parties
- Pay by result or fixed price where possible
- No integration into duty rosters, holiday planning or hierarchy
- Liability and warranty as between businesses
- Rules on rights of use
Depending on whether a result or an activity is owed, a Contract for work or a Service contract is suitable.
Typical sectors
- IT and software: Long-term assignments in client teams with fixed hours are risky.
- Care and health: Freelance nurses and freelance doctors in hospitals are usually considered employed.
- Education: Following case law of the Federal Social Court, the social insurance institutions have tightened their standards for teachers. Lecturers at universities, adult education centres, music schools and private educational institutions are considered employed if, for example, they must work personally, are given times and rooms and receive a cancellation fee.
- Construction and trades: Subcontractors who only work for one construction company.
- Commercial agents: An earlier special rule no longer exists. Anyone who can essentially organise their work and working hours freely is self-employed.
- Media: Freelancers in editorial offices with fixed shifts.
FAQ
What is the 5/6 rule?
It concerns self-employed persons similar to employees without their own staff who earn at least five sixths of their income from one client. They remain self-employed but are subject to compulsory pension insurance.
How do I recognise bogus self-employment?
By instructions on the time, place and manner of work, by integration into the client's business and by the absence of entrepreneurial risk.
When is there no bogus self-employment?
When you decide freely about your work, have several clients, bear your own risk and present yourself on the market.
Who is penalised for bogus self-employment?
Above all, the client. It must pay contributions retrospectively and may commit an offence under Sec. 266a StGB.
How long can the pension insurance claim back payments?
Four years after the end of the calendar year in which the contributions became due, thirty years for deliberately withheld contributions.
Is a good freelance contract enough?
No. What matters is the actual collaboration. A suitable contract is still important because it documents the self-employment.
About the author
Dr. Georg Schröder, LL.M.
Dr. Georg Schröder is a lawyer and writes the guides of Recht 24/7. He explains legal questions so that you can follow them without legal training, and he reviews every guide before it is published.
View author profile


