In short
The local comparative rent (ortsübliche Vergleichsmiete) is the rent agreed or changed for comparable flats in your municipality over the last six years. The comparison is based on type, size, fittings, condition, location and energy standard (Sec. 558 (2) BGB). The easiest way to find it is the local rent index (Mietspiegel). It is the upper limit for a normal rent increase and the reference value for the rent cap: for new lettings in rent cap areas, the rent may be no more than 10 percent above it.
Key points
- The comparative rent is not a fixed figure but usually a range from the rent index.
- Municipalities with more than 50,000 inhabitants must produce a rent index (Sec. 558c (4) BGB).
- A qualified rent index carries special weight: it is presumed to reflect the comparative rent correctly (Sec. 558d BGB).
- If there is no rent index, the landlord can refer to a rent database, an expert opinion or three comparable flats.
- Before an increase, the rent must have been unchanged for 15 months, and the landlord may demand it no earlier than one year after the last increase.
- You have until the end of the second calendar month after receiving the request for an increase to agree.
Contents
| What the comparative rent is used for | Rule | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| Rent increase in an existing contract | at most up to the comparative rent and at most 20% in three years (15% in tight areas) | Sec. 558 BGB |
| New letting under the rent cap | at most 10% above the comparative rent | Sec. 556d BGB |
| Excessive rent | more than 20% above usual rents while exploiting a short supply is an administrative offence | Sec. 5 WiStG |
What the local comparative rent is
The comparative rent is an average of the rents actually paid in the municipality or a comparable municipality. The law sets two limits:
- Only rents from the last six years count, i.e. new lettings and rent increases during that period. Mere increases in operating costs are not included.
- Only freely agreed rents count. Flats whose rent is set by law or because of public funding, for example social housing, are not taken into account.
Only flats similar to yours are compared. The criteria are set out in the law:
- Type: for example old or new building, apartment block or detached house
- Size: the living space
- Fittings: for example bathroom, kitchen, balcony, floor coverings, lift
- Condition: year of construction, layout, state of repair
- Location: residential area within the town, noise, transport links
- Energy fittings and condition: insulation, windows, heating
How to find the comparative rent
To justify a rent increase, Sec. 558a (2) BGB names four ways:
| Means of justification | What it is | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Rent index | overview by the municipality or by tenant and landlord associations | simple rent index: indication; qualified rent index: statutory presumption |
| Rent database | continuously maintained collection of rents, kept or recognised by the municipality or the associations | rare in practice |
| Expert opinion | reasoned opinion of a publicly appointed and sworn expert | costs money, the court can review it |
| Three comparable flats | naming three flats with similar features and their rent | sufficient as justification, but proves little |
If there is a qualified rent index with figures for your flat, the landlord must state these values in the request for an increase even if they justify the increase differently, for example with three comparable flats (Sec. 558a (3) BGB). This means you can always compare.
Reading the rent index correctly
You can get the rent index from your city or municipality; many publish it online, often with an online calculator. This is how to proceed:
- Find the right field: The rent index is usually broken down by year of construction (ready for occupancy), size of flat and residential location.
- Read the range: For each field there is an average value and a range in euros per square metre of basic rent.
- Check surcharges and deductions: Many rent indexes have features that move the value up or down, for example a fitted kitchen, balcony, lift, modernised bathroom or poor thermal insulation.
- Convert to the living space: Multiply the value per square metre by the actual living space.
If the landlord refers to a rent index with ranges, it is enough for the justification that the rent requested is within the range (Sec. 558a (4) BGB). Whether it is justified in the upper part of the range depends on the features of the flat. In the event of a dispute, a court decides.
If the rent in the contract is a gross rent, i.e. including operating costs, you must first deduct the operating costs before comparing it with the rent index.
Rent increase up to the comparative rent
If the landlord wants to increase the rent in an existing contract and no graduated or index-linked rent has been agreed, they may ask for your consent to an increase up to the local comparative rent. Three limits apply (Sec. 558 BGB):
- Unchanged for 15 months: At the time the increase is to take effect, the rent must have remained the same for 15 months.
- One-year block: The request may come no earlier than one year after the last increase.
- Rent increase cap: Within three years, the rent may rise by no more than 20 percent. In areas designated by the state government by ordinance, the limit is 15 percent.
Increases due to modernisation or higher operating costs do not count towards these limits.
Example
The flat is 70 m² and has cost an unchanged 595 euros basic rent for three years, i.e. 8.50 euros per m². According to the rent index, the comparative rent for the relevant field is 9.80 euros per m², which is 686 euros. The 20 percent cap allows a maximum of 714 euros. The landlord may therefore increase the rent up to 686 euros, because the comparative rent is the lower limit. If the 15 percent cap applies in the city, at most 684.25 euros would be possible.
The request for an increase must be in text form and justified. If you agree, you pay the new rent from the third calendar month after receipt. If you do not agree by the end of the second calendar month, the landlord can sue for consent within a further three months (Sec. 558b BGB). Everything about form and deadlines is in the guides Rent increase and Rent increase: deadlines.
Comparative rent and the rent cap
In areas with a tight housing market, the rent at the start of a new tenancy may exceed the local comparative rent by no more than 10 percent (Sec. 556d BGB). The state government determines by ordinance which municipalities are affected. There are exceptions, for example for new builds, after comprehensive modernisation or if the previous rent was already higher. How to reclaim rent that is too high is explained in the guide Rent cap.
There is also a limit outside the rent cap: if a landlord, exploiting a short supply, demands more than 20 percent above the usual rents, this is an administrative offence (Sec. 5 WiStG). However, the hurdles for this are high in practice.
What tenants and landlords should check
As a tenant:
- Is the field chosen in the rent index correct, i.e. year of construction, size and location?
- Have all deductions been taken into account, for example missing fittings or a poor energy standard?
- Is the living space in the request for an increase correct?
- Have the 15 months, the one-year block and the rent increase cap been observed?
- Has a graduated or index-linked rent been agreed? Then an increase to the comparative rent is excluded.
As a landlord:
- A qualified rent index must be stated in the request, even if you use a different justification.
- Read the rent index with all the features of the flat, not just the average value.
- Plan the deadlines so that the 15 months are met at the time the increase takes effect.
Checklist: determining the comparative rent
Checklist: comparative rent
- Get the current rent index for the municipality, simple or qualified?
- Clarify the year of construction, living space and location of the flat
- Read the relevant field with average value and range
- Check surcharges and deductions for fittings and energy standard
- Multiply the value per square metre by the living space
- Compare with the current basic rent
- Check against the rent increase cap of 20 or 15 percent in three years
FAQ
How do I calculate the local comparative rent?
Find the field in the rent index for the year of construction, size and location of your flat, take the surcharges and deductions into account and multiply the value per square metre by the living space.
Where can I find the local comparative rent?
In the rent index of your city or municipality, usually on its website. If there is none, a rent index of a comparable municipality, a rent database or an expert opinion can help.
What is the difference between a simple and a qualified rent index?
The qualified rent index is drawn up according to recognised scientific principles and officially recognised. It is presumed to reflect the comparative rent correctly. A simple rent index is only an indication.
May the landlord increase the rent above the comparative rent?
Not under Sec. 558 BGB. Higher rents are only possible for new lettings outside the rent cap, through an agreed graduated or index-linked rent or after modernisation.
How old may the comparative rents be?
Rents agreed or changed in the last six years count.
Do I have to agree to a rent increase to the comparative rent?
Yes, if it is formally correct and justified in substance. Otherwise the landlord can sue for consent. Check the justification, deadlines and rent increase cap first.
Terms used in this guide
About the author
Dr. Georg Schröder, LL.M.
Dr. Georg Schröder is a lawyer and writes the guides of Recht 24/7. He explains legal questions so that you can follow them without legal training, and he reviews every guide before it is published.
View author profile


