In short
If your flat has a defect that noticeably impairs its use, the rent is automatically reduced for as long as the defect exists (Sec. 536 BGB). How much depends on the individual case. There is no statutory table, but courts have decided many cases. The calculation is based on the gross rent, i.e. including service charges. Important: report the defect immediately, and if in doubt, pay under reservation rather than withholding too much.
Key points
- The reduction applies by law; the landlord does not have to agree.
- Insignificant defects do not entitle you to a reduction (Sec. 536 (1) sentence 3 BGB).
- You must report the defect without delay, otherwise you lose the right to reduce the rent for the time before (Sec. 536c BGB).
- If you knew about the defect when you signed the contract, you cannot reduce the rent (Sec. 536b BGB).
- In the case of an energy-saving modernisation, a reduction is excluded for three months (Sec. 536 (1a) BGB).
- Anyone who reduces too much and thereby falls into arrears risks dismissal.
Contents
- When may you reduce the rent?
- Rent reduction table: decisions with case numbers
- How to calculate the reduction
- Step by step: from reporting the defect to the reduction
- When a reduction is excluded
- Reduction or withholding?
- Beware of paying without reservation
- Contract clauses cannot exclude the reduction
- Defect known on moving in, then a rent increase
- Demand a repair or remedy it yourself
- Landlord refuses: what now
- Common defects briefly explained
- FAQ
When may you reduce the rent?
Requirements under Sec. 536 BGB:
- Defect: The flat deviates from the condition owed under the contract, for example due to mould, heating failure, noise from a construction site or a significantly smaller living space.
- Significant: Use is noticeably impaired. A dripping tap is usually not enough.
- Not caused by you: If you caused the defect, for example through incorrect ventilation, there is no reduction. Who caused mould is often disputed.
- Reported: The landlord must know about the defect.
- Not known when the contract was signed: If you knew about the defect and signed anyway without reserving your rights, a reduction is excluded.
A special rule applies to living space: if the flat is more than ten percent smaller than stated in the contract, there is in principle a defect, even if the contract says "approx." You then do not have to prove in addition that use is impaired, and the rent is reduced in proportion to the entire deviation (BGH, 24.03.2004, VIII ZR 295/03 and VIII ZR 133/03).
Rent reduction table: decisions with case numbers
There is no fixed or binding reduction rate for particular defects. Courts always decide the individual case, and many well-known decisions are decades old. The table therefore only shows the range in which courts have reduced the rent in comparable cases. We have only included decisions listed with the same reference in several independent case collections.
| Defect | Reduction | Court and reference |
|---|---|---|
| Heating and water | ||
| Room temperature only 15 °C | 25% | AG Berlin-Neukölln, 10 C 557/84 |
| Faulty thermostatic valves | 8% | LG Berlin, ZMR 2003, 487 |
| Failure of the water supply | 20% | LG Berlin, MM 2002, 427 |
| Damp and mould | ||
| Water dripping from the ceiling, carpet soaked | 50% | AG Leverkusen, WuM 1980, 163 |
| Water dripping from the ceiling | 30% | AG Kiel, WuM 1980, 235 |
| Severe damp in kitchen, living room and bedroom, mould, musty smell | 80% | LG Berlin, GE 1991, 625 |
| Damp and mould in several rooms due to leaky windows | 20% | AG Hamburg, WuM 1979, 103 |
| Visible water stains in the flat | 2% | LG Hannover, WuM 1994, 463 |
| Noise and construction | ||
| Large construction site in the neighbourhood, partly at night | 12% | LG Frankfurt, ZMR 2007, 699 |
| Fittings and condition | ||
| Defective telephone line | 10% | LG Essen, 21.07.2016, 10 S 43/16 |
| Only one underground car park key for a married couple | 5% | LG Bonn, 6 S 90/09 |
| Peeling paint and loose plaster in the stairwell | 5% | LG Köln, WuM 1990, 17 |
| Vermin | ||
| Rat infestation of a ground-floor flat, control over two weeks | 80% | AG Dülmen, 3 C 128/12 |
WuM, ZMR, GE and MM are specialist journals in which the decisions are published. Do not apply a rate to your case without checking it.
How to calculate the reduction
The basis is the gross rent: basic rent plus advance payments or a flat rate for service charges (BGH, 06.04.2005, XII ZR 225/03).
Formula: gross rent × reduction rate = reduction amount per month
Example
Your gross rent is 1,000 euros. Mould is growing in the bedroom, and you apply 15 percent. Reduction: 1,000 × 0.15 = 150 euros per month. If the defect only exists for part of the month, for example ten days, calculate proportionally: 150 × 10 ÷ 30 = 50 euros.
Step by step: from reporting the defect to the reduction
- Document the defect: Dated photos, and for temperature or noise a log with readings and times.
- Report the defect: In writing, ideally by letter with proof of delivery or by email with read receipt. Describe the defect, its location and when it started, and ask for it to be remedied within a reasonable period.
- Allow access: Let tradespeople into the flat, otherwise you cannot reduce the rent for this time.
- Pay under reservation: If you are unsure how high the reduction is, pay the full rent and state in writing that you are paying subject to reclaiming it. This protects you from arrears and dismissal.
- Reduce: Reduce the rent from the month in which the defect existed and was reported, or reclaim overpaid rent later.
- Withhold: In addition, you may withhold part of the rent until the defect is remedied in order to put on pressure. You must pay this amount after the repair.
Checklist: defect report
- Date and your address
- Exact description of the defect and where it occurs
- Since when the defect has existed
- Photos or log attached
- Request for remedy with a deadline
- Note that you reserve the right to reduce the rent
- Times when tradespeople can access the flat
When a reduction is excluded
- You knew about the defect when you signed the contract or took over the flat without reservation despite knowing about it (Sec. 536b BGB).
- You did not report the defect, and the landlord could therefore not repair it (Sec. 536c (2) BGB).
- You caused the defect yourself.
- The impairment is insignificant.
- For the first three months of an energy-saving modernisation (Sec. 536 (1a) BGB).
- You prevent the repair, for example by not letting tradespeople into the flat.
Reduction or withholding?
| Rent reduction | Right of retention | |
|---|---|---|
| Effect | rent is permanently lower for the duration of the defect | part of the rent is temporarily not paid |
| Money back? | no, the amount is gone for good | you must pay it after the remedy |
| Purpose | compensation for restricted use | means of pressure for the repair |
| Legal basis | Sec. 536 BGB | Sec. 320 BGB |
| Amount and duration | reasonable rate | limited in the individual case, proportionate to the defect and only as long as it can put pressure on the repair (BGH, 17.06.2015, VIII ZR 19/14) |
Beware of paying without reservation
If you continue to pay the full rent despite a defect without declaring a reservation, you do not lose the right to reduce the rent in future. However, you may no longer be able to reclaim the rent already paid, even if you have complained (cf. BGH, 16.07.2003, VIII ZR 274/02). So state in the defect report that from now on you are only paying under reservation.
Contract clauses cannot exclude the reduction
For residential premises, any agreement that restricts the right to reduce the rent to your detriment is invalid (Sec. 536 (4) BGB). You do not have to observe a clause such as "The reduction must be announced in writing in advance". It is enough that you have reported the defect.
Defect known on moving in, then a rent increase
If you knew about a defect when you signed the contract, you generally cannot reduce the rent because of it (Sec. 536b BGB). If the landlord later increases the rent, the right to reduce may revive according to a widespread view, because the landlord is then changing the original agreement.
Demand a repair or remedy it yourself
In addition to the reduction, you are entitled to have the landlord remedy the defect (Sec. 535 (1) BGB). If the landlord remains inactive despite the defect report and deadline, they are in default. You may then have the defect remedied yourself and claim the necessary costs (Sec. 536a (2) BGB). This also applies if an immediate repair is necessary to prevent greater damage, for example a burst pipe. You may offset this claim against the rent, even if the contract excludes this, provided you announce it in text form at least one month before the rent is due (Sec. 556b (2) BGB).
Landlord refuses: what now
The landlord does not have to agree to the reduction; it applies by law. However, the landlord can claim that there is no defect or that you caused it. Then it becomes risky:
- Reduction too high: If you deduct more than justified, rent arrears arise. If they reach two months' rent or you are in arrears with a not insignificant part in two consecutive months, the landlord can terminate without notice (Sec. 543 (2) no. 3 BGB). A mistake about the amount does not protect you.
- Safe route: Pay under reservation and reclaim the overpaid rent, if necessary through a lawsuit.
- Declaratory action: You can have a court confirm that the rent is reduced.
Common defects briefly explained
Mould
Tenants and landlords often argue about whether structural defects or incorrect ventilation are the cause. In the case of a structural defect, the landlord must remedy it and you can reduce the rent. An expert can clarify the cause.
Heating failure
During the heating season, usually from October to April, the heating must reach about 20 to 22 °C during the day. If it fails completely, high rates are possible.
Outside noise and construction noise
Noise that comes from outside and arises after the contract was signed, for example from a new football pitch or a neighbouring construction site, is not automatically a defect. The Federal Court of Justice asks whether the landlord would also have to tolerate the noise without compensation. If so, you usually cannot reduce the rent (BGH, 29.04.2015, VIII ZR 197/14, football pitch; confirmed for construction noise in 2020, VIII ZR 31/18). It is different with noise from the building itself, for example from the landlord's construction work.
Telephone, internet and TV
If a connection provided by the landlord does not work, for example the telephone socket, this can be a defect. LG Essen awarded 10 percent for a defective telephone line (10 S 43/16). Faults in your own devices or with the provider are not a defect of the flat.
Vermin
Rats, mice or cockroaches that are not due to your behaviour are a defect. With a severe infestation, high rates are possible, for example 80 percent for a rat infestation in a ground-floor flat (AG Dülmen, 3 C 128/12).
Heat in summer
High temperatures on hot days alone are not a defect. If it becomes permanently unbearably hot due to poor insulation, a reduction may be considered. Court decisions on this vary.
Water damage
In addition to the damp itself, drying equipment with its noise and electricity consumption counts. You do not have to bear the electricity costs of the drying equipment if the landlord is responsible for the damage. Record the meter reading before and after drying.
FAQ
What percentage can you reduce?
That depends on the defect. For minor defects it is a few percent, for a completely unusable flat up to 100 percent. The table above shows decisions with rates and case numbers.
How do I calculate the rent reduction?
Gross rent times the reduction rate. With a gross rent of 1,000 euros and 15 percent, that is 150 euros a month.
Does the landlord have to accept the reduction?
No, the landlord does not have to agree. The reduction applies automatically if a significant defect exists and has been reported.
How much can I reduce for mould?
That depends on the area, the rooms and the health risk. Courts have awarded anything from a few percent up to 80 percent for severe damp in several rooms (LG Berlin, GE 1991, 625).
How much for heating failure in winter?
With a complete failure in winter, very high rates are possible. Where the flat only reached about 15 °C, a court awarded 25 percent (AG Berlin-Neukölln, 10 C 557/84).
May I reduce retrospectively?
Yes, from the time the defect existed and was reported. If you continued to pay the full rent without reservation, the claim for repayment may be limited (cf. BGH, VIII ZR 274/02).
Can I be evicted because of a rent reduction?
Only if you have reduced too much and significant arrears arise as a result. Paying under reservation avoids this risk.
About the author
Dr. Georg Schröder, LL.M.
Dr. Georg Schröder is a lawyer and writes the guides of Recht 24/7. He explains legal questions so that you can follow them without legal training, and he reviews every guide before it is published.
View author profile


