In short
By law, the landlord must keep the flat in good condition, which includes redecorating it (Sec. 535 (1) sentence 2 BGB). The landlord can only transfer this to you as a tenant with a valid clause in the tenancy agreement. Many clauses are invalid, for example rigid deadlines, an obligation to redecorate when moving out or pro-rata clauses. If you took over the flat unrenovated and received no compensation, you usually do not have to redecorate at all. So check your contract first.
Key points
- Cosmetic repairs are work such as painting walls, ceilings, radiators, interior doors and windows from the inside.
- Without a valid clause, you do not have to redecorate, not even when you move out.
- Invalid clauses include rigid schedules, final redecoration clauses regardless of condition, pro-rata clauses and colour requirements during the tenancy.
- If the flat was taken over unrenovated, a redecoration clause without reasonable compensation is invalid.
- The landlord's claims relating to the condition become time-barred six months after the flat is returned (Sec. 548 BGB).
Contents
- What counts as cosmetic repairs?
- Who has to redecorate?
- Clause check: typical clauses at a glance
- Took over the flat unrenovated: what now?
- Do I have to paint when I move out?
- Already redecorated even though you did not have to?
- Landlord demands money after you move out
- For landlords: agreeing cosmetic repairs validly
- FAQ
What counts as cosmetic repairs?
Case law is based on the definition in Sec. 28 (4) sentence 3 of the Second Calculation Ordinance.
| Counts | Does not count |
|---|---|
| Wallpapering and painting walls and ceilings | Sanding and sealing parquet |
| Painting radiators and heating pipes | Replacing carpet |
| Painting interior doors | Repairing damage, e.g. broken tiles |
| Painting windows and exterior doors from the inside | Painting windows from the outside |
| Cleaning or painting floors, where usual | Replacing sanitary fittings |
These must be distinguished from damage you caused, for example a burn mark in the carpet or many large drill holes in tiles. You are liable for this regardless of any redecoration clause.
Who has to redecorate?
In principle, the landlord. The landlord must keep the flat in the contractual condition during the tenancy. In a standard-form tenancy agreement, the landlord may only transfer this obligation to you if the clause does not unreasonably disadvantage you (Sec. 307 BGB). If the clause is invalid, the statutory rule remains, and the landlord must redecorate.
Clause check: typical clauses at a glance
| Clause in the tenancy agreement | Valid? | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| "The tenant bears the costs of cosmetic repairs" (flat handed over renovated) | yes | BGH, 14.07.2004, VIII ZR 339/03 |
| Rigid schedule: "kitchen and bathroom every 3 years, living rooms every 5 years" | no | BGH, 23.06.2004, VIII ZR 361/03 |
| Flexible schedule: "generally", "as a rule" after certain years | yes, if the actual condition remains decisive | settled BGH case law |
| Final redecoration when moving out, regardless of when it was last done | no | BGH, 12.09.2007, VIII ZR 316/06 |
| Pro-rata clause: share of costs if redecoration is not yet needed | no | BGH, 18.03.2015, VIII ZR 242/13 |
| Colour requirements during the tenancy, e.g. "white only" | no | BGH, 18.06.2008, VIII ZR 224/07 |
| Return "painted white" | no | BGH, 14.12.2010, VIII ZR 198/10 |
| "Neutral, light colours on return" | yes, usually | |
| Painting windows and doors on the outside, or just "paint windows and doors" without limiting it to the inside | no | BGH, 13.01.2010, VIII ZR 48/09 |
| Obligation to hire a specialist firm | no, competent own work is enough | BGH, 09.06.2010, VIII ZR 294/09 |
| Redecoration obligation for a flat handed over unrenovated without compensation | no | BGH, 18.03.2015, VIII ZR 185/14 |
If a clause on cosmetic repairs is invalid, the entire transfer usually falls away. The landlord cannot reduce it to a permissible extent. Nor may the landlord demand a higher rent just because the clause is invalid (BGH, 09.07.2008, VIII ZR 83/07). It may be different for a genuine individual agreement negotiated in detail. Such an agreement is usually valid.
Took over the flat unrenovated: what now?
If you took over the flat unrenovated or in need of redecoration and received no reasonable compensation, for example a rent-free period, a clause that transfers cosmetic repairs to you is invalid. The Federal Court of Justice ruled this in 2015 (BGH, 18.03.2015, VIII ZR 185/14). Unrenovated means: the rooms do not give the overall impression of a renovated flat, so there are more than just insignificant signs of use. You then do not have to redecorate either during the tenancy or when you move out.
Conversely, in this case you can ask the landlord to redecorate if the condition has deteriorated significantly during the tenancy. However, you will usually have to pay half the costs, because the redecoration gives you a better flat than the one you took over.
Important: record the condition when you move in with a handover record and photos. In the event of a dispute, you must prove that the flat was unrenovated.
Do I have to paint when I move out?
Go through these questions in order:
- Does the contract contain a clause on cosmetic repairs? No: you do not have to redecorate.
- Did you take over the flat renovated or receive compensation? No: the clause is usually invalid.
- Does the clause contain rigid deadlines, a final redecoration, a pro-rata share or a colour requirement during the tenancy? Yes: the clause is invalid.
- Does the flat actually need redecorating? No: you do not have to redecorate, even if the clause is valid.
- Is everything valid and does the flat need redecorating? Then you must carry out the usual work competently, yourself or with help.
Regardless of this, you must repair damage that goes beyond normal wear and tear. Normal dowel holes to the usual extent are usually considered use in accordance with the contract.
Already redecorated even though you did not have to?
If you redecorated when moving out because you thought an invalid clause was valid, you can claim compensation for the value from the landlord. For your own work, you usually get the cost of materials and payment for helpers from your family and circle of friends, not the price of a painting firm (BGH, 27.05.2009, VIII ZR 302/07). The claim becomes time-barred six months after the end of the tenancy (Sec. 548 (2) BGB).
Landlord demands money after you move out
If the landlord thinks you should have redecorated, they must usually first ask you to redecorate and set a deadline before they can claim damages. Only then may they hire a painter and claim the costs, often by deducting them from the deposit.
Limitation: The landlord's claims for changes to or deterioration of the flat become time-barred six months after the flat is returned (Sec. 548 (1) BGB). If the landlord asserts them for the first time after that, you can rely on the limitation period. More about the deposit in the guide Rental deposit.
For landlords: agreeing cosmetic repairs validly
- Hand over the flat renovated or agree and document reasonable compensation.
- No rigid deadlines; refer to the actual condition.
- No final redecoration regardless of condition.
- No pro-rata clause.
- Colour requirements only for the condition on return, and only "neutral and light".
- Have existing contracts checked before making claims when a tenant moves out.
FAQ
Which cosmetic repairs do I have to do when I move out?
Only if your contract contains a valid clause and the flat needs redecorating. Then typically painting walls and ceilings, radiators, interior doors and windows from the inside.
When is the clause invalid?
Among other things, with rigid deadlines, final redecoration regardless of condition, pro-rata clauses, colour requirements during the tenancy and for a flat taken over unrenovated without compensation.
Do I have to fill holes in the wall?
Normal dowel holes to the usual extent are usually part of use in accordance with the contract. Many or large drill holes, for example in tiles, can be damage for which you are liable.
Do I have to paint the walls white?
An obligation to use white during the tenancy is invalid. On return, the landlord can demand neutral, light colours if this has been validly agreed. You should paint over bright colours before moving out.
May the landlord require a professional painter?
No, a clause requiring a specialist firm is invalid. You may paint yourself if the work is done competently.
What applies if I took over the flat unrenovated?
Without reasonable compensation, you do not have to redecorate. The clause is invalid.
About the author
Dr. Georg Schröder, LL.M.
Dr. Georg Schröder is a lawyer and writes the guides of Recht 24/7. He explains legal questions so that you can follow them without legal training, and he reviews every guide before it is published.
View author profile


