From accident to complaint - a chain reaction with a bang
A short text message ended in a fine for a pensioner from Tübingen that you would normally expect for large-scale tax evasion: 240,000 euros for attempted bribery. And all because of a single text message.
The story begins in November 2021: a then 68-year-old woman witnesses a hit-and-run - someone hits her car and then simply speeds off. Instead of calling the police directly, she tries to find out more on her own. She memorizes the license plate number and writes a message to a police officer. In it, she asks for the owner's details - and offers to "make herself recognizable". That sounds like bribery to the court - even if the woman presumably just wanted to put a bit of pressure on the police to get information.
SMS discovered by chance - during a completely different investigation
Explosive: The content of this message would probably never have become known if her cell phone had not been confiscated and analyzed as part of a completely different investigation. The text message in question was discovered in the process. The police officer had neither responded to it nor reported it. However, the public prosecutor's office found enough material in it for a penalty order.
And it was a hefty one: the pensioner was ordered to pay a whopping 240,000 euros. That's a sum that makes many people gasp - but in Germany, the amount of a fine is based on income. If you have a lot, you pay more.
A bribe? Or a misunderstanding with costly consequences?
The woman initially did not pay. As a result, the local court had to reassess the case. The media later even reported on a penalty order for 300,000 euros.
For the court, however, the facts of the case were clear: the wording in the text message was deemed to be a clear attempt to persuade an officer to act unlawfully. Whether the officer responded or not was irrelevant. The attempt alone was sufficient.
If you have a lot, you pay a lot - but is that still fair?
Keine Frage: Beamte dürfen keine Daten weitergeben, und wer das versucht zu umgehen, überschreitet eine Grenze. Aber 240.000 Euro für eine SMS? Auch wenn sich die Höhe der Strafe am Vermögen orientiert – hier wird deutlich, wie wenig Maß und Mitte in manchen Urteilen zu finden ist. Eine Rentnerin, die versucht, einen Unfallflüchtigen zu überführen, wird kriminalisiert – statt ihr zu danken, packt man den Vorschlaghammer aus. Ob das dem Gerechtigkeitsempfinden vieler Bürger entspricht? Fraglich.
Avoid high penalties due to careless text messages. Book a consultation now and protect yourself from legal consequences!
to the lawyerAt a fixed price of 119 EURO (gross)
