Online law firm since 2003

Available 24/7

Satisfaction guarantee

Trusted by over 60,000 clients

Recht 24/7
Back to overview
Legal

Important ruling against subscription traps

Oct 9, 20232 min read

One of the biggest pitfalls with online subscriptions is the so-called "subscription trap". Users who take out a free trial subscription and miss the notice period often find themselves in long-term, fee-based contracts.

When a second right of withdrawal applies

The ECJ has sent a decisive message to companies with a recent ruling: Consumer protection is a top priority. If consumers fall into the subscription trap because they were not sufficiently informed about the conditions of the subscription, they have the right to cancel this subscription a second time.

In concrete terms, this means that even if the original right of withdrawal has already been exhausted, consumers can assert a further right of withdrawal if they have not been expressly informed of the costs and conditions of the subsequent paid subscription. This second right of withdrawal gives consumers an additional layer of security.

European Court of Justice rules in the "Sofa Tutor" case

The Luxembourg judges made it clear that they recognize the importance of consumer protection in the digital world. They demand that consumers must be informed clearly and comprehensibly about their rights. Vague or difficult-to-understand wording that could mislead consumers will not be tolerated.

The ruling is a victory for consumer protection in Europe. It shows that companies must communicate transparently and comprehensibly and that they can be held accountable for improper actions.

Conclusion

The ECJ's decision sends a strong signal to companies offering online subscriptions. Consumer protection is the focus and companies must ensure that they provide clear and transparent information about the terms and conditions of their services.

At a time when online services and subscriptions are becoming increasingly popular, it is important that consumers know their rights and can be confident that they are protected. The ECJ's ruling strengthens confidence in the digital market and sets a standard for consumer rights in Europe.

Do you have a specific legal question?

Our lawyers advise you online at a fixed price: fast, clear and without an office appointment.

Get started

Your case starts here.

Personal advice
Directly from a lawyer

Transparent fixed prices
with no surprises.

Response within
24 hours

Securely insured
up to €2.5 million

No legal jargon, just clear answers.

The Recht 24/7 newsletter: deadlines, rulings and tips for founders and clients. Once a month.

I have read the privacy policy. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Trusted Shops
Trusted Shops

4.89/5

| 677 reviews

Verified client · Contract check · April 2026 · Translated from German

Very fast, very thorough, very professional!: The fast and professional evaluation and assessment of my contract helped me make an informed decision. All around very fast, very thorough, very professional!

Verified client · Contract review, apartment purchase · February 2026 · Translated from German

Expectations were exceeded!: At first I was skeptical whether the online service would measure up to a personal conversation with a lawyer. But Recht 24/7 exceeded my expectations. Highly qualified staff, fast response times.

Verified client · Legal advice · June 2026 · Translated from German

Great experience, the processing happens in a truly unbeatable time. For me, with two orders, already in under 24 h, and that at a price that is completely unbeaten compared to the market.

Verified client · GmbH liquidation · January 2026 · Translated from German

Support with the liquidation of a GmbH: The responses always came very promptly, and my questions were answered clearly and understandably. My expectations were not only met but exceeded. Recommended without reservation.